Engineering Transactions, 30, 3-4, pp. 369-396, 1982

The Constructive Uses of Aeroelasticity

H. Ashley
Stanford University, Stanford
United States

L.L. Lehman
Stanford University, Stanford
United States

J.K. Nathman
Stanford University, Stanford
United States

Dedicated to Professor Władysław Piszdon on the occasion of his seventieth birthday
Historical, previously-published and new material is illustrated and discussed in support of the proposition that static or dynamic structural deformations of aerospace vehicles can often be used for constructive purposes. Examples are presented chronologically in categories related to the intended function. Efficient control of flight is attainable, as by the Wrights' wing warping. Constraints can be relaxed on the performance of high-speed aircraft, fixed-pithc propellers and rotors. Accelerations and loads in rough air are diminished. Aeroelastic deformations furnish a means for primary propulsion. Prospects for the future are examined, notably the "complete aeroelastic CCV".

Full Text: PDF
Copyright © Polish Academy of Sciences & Institute of Fundamental Technological Research (IPPT PAN).


W. FISZDON, Fundamentals of aeroelasticity, PWN, Warsaw 1951 [in Polish].

Y. C. FUJNG, An introduction to the theory of aeroelasticity, John Wiley and Sons, New York 1955.

R. L. BISPLINGHOFF, H. ASHLEY, R. L. HALFMAN, Aeroelasticity, Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, Reading, MA 1955.

E. H. DOWELL, H. C. CURTISS Jr., H. C. SCANLAN, F. SISTO, A modern course in aeroelasticity, Sijthoff and Noordhoff, The Netherlands 1978.

A. R. COLLAR, The first fifty years of aeroelasticity, Aerospace, 5, 2, 12-20, February 1978.

H. COOMBS, M. CAIDIN, KilL devil hiLI, Houghton Mifflin Company, 61, 69-72, Boston 1979,

F. E. C. CULICK, The origins of the first powered, man-carrying airplane, Scientific American, 241, 1, 86-100, July 1979.

J. D. ANDERSON Jr., Introduction to flight, McGraw-Hill Book Company, 293-294, New York 1978.

P. B. S. LISSAMAN, Wings for human-power flight, The Evolution of Aircraft Wing Design, 49-56, Proc. of a Conference sponsored by AIAA, Air Force Museum, Dayton, OH, March 1980.

J. D. BURKE, The Gossamer Condor and Albatros. A case study in Aircraft Design, Report No. AV-R-80/540, Aerovironment, Inc., Pasadena, CA, June 1980 (prepared for AIAA Profes­sional Study Series, Five Case Studies in Aircraft Design).

R. B. BROWN, K. F. HoLTBY, H. C. MARTIN, A superposition method for calculating the aero-elastic behavior of swept wings, J. Aero. Sci., 18, 8, 531-542, August 1951.

C. D. PERKINS, Development of airplane stability and control technology, J. Aircraft, 7, 4, 290-301, July-August 1980.

D. KEITH-LUCAS, The shape of wings to come, Flight, 64, 2279, 408-410, 26 September 1952. (See also Flight, 64, 2334, 535, and 64, 2339, 680-681).

B. E. JONES, Preliminary quasi-steady aeroelastic analysis of the F-111 airplane. Ft. Worth Di­vision, General Dynamics Corp., Report FZS-12-176, July 1966.

R. T. JONES, Reduction of wave drag by antisymmetric arangement of wings and bodies, AIAA J., 10, 12, 171-176, February 1972.

E. J. HOPKINS, S. C. YEE, Effect of wing flexibility on the experimental aerodynamic charac­teristics of an oblique wing, NASA TMX-2460, March 1977.

D. M. BucK, R. W. MENTHE, H. S. WAINAUSKI, Aerodynamic design and performance testing of an advanced 30 degree swept, eight-bladed propeller at Mach numbers from 0.2 to 0.85, NASA CR-3047, September 1978.

M. M. MUNK, Propeller containing diagonally disposed fibrous material, U.S. Patent No. 2, 484, 308, October 11, 1949 (filed August 25, 1947).

E. HOADLEY, A new twist in props, Flying, July 1951.

J. B. ROGERS, Aeroelastically tailored propellers, Master's Thesis, The University of Texas at Austin, May 1976.

E. E. LARRABEE, Design of propellers for motorsoarers, Intl. Symposium of the Aerodynamics of Low Speed and Motorless Flight, NASA Conference Publication 2085, Part I, 1978.

E. E. LARRABEE, Composite material propellers, Summary report for NASA Langley Research Center, April 1977.

J. L. McCLOUD, A. L. WEISBRICH, Wind-tunnel test results of a full-scale multicyclic controllable twist rotor, Preprint No. 78-60, Annual National Forum, American Helicopter Society, Wa­shington, May 1978.

R. H. BLACKWELL, D. J. MERKLBY, The aeroelastically conformable rotor concept, Preprint No. 78-59, Annual National Forum, American Helicopter Society, Washington, May 1978.

G. S. DOMAN, F. J. TARZANIN, J. SHAW Jr., Investigation of aeroelastically adaptive rotor sys­tems, Proc. American Helicopter Society Mideast Region Symposium on Rotor Technology, Washington, August 1976.

R. V. BRULLE, H. C. LARSEN, Giromill cyclogiro-windmill investigation Jor generation of elastic power, Proceedings, Second Workshop of Wind Energy Conversion Systems, Mitre Corp, MTR-6970, 452-460, Washington, September 1975.

H. ASHLEY, Some contributions to aerodynamic theory for vertical axis wind turbines, J. Energy., 2, 2, 113-119, March/April 1978.

T. A. WEISSHAAR, Aeroelastic stability and performance characteristics of aircraft with advanced composite sweptforward wing structures, AFFDL-TR 78-116, U.S. Air Force Flight Dynamics Lab, September 1978.

T. A. WEISSHAAR, Forward swept wing aeroelasticity, AFFDL-TR-79-3087, U.S. Air Force Flight Dynamics Lab, June 1979.

J. G. WILLIAMS, Analysis/theory of controlled configured structures, AFFDL-TR-74-137, U.S. Air Force Flight Dynamics Lab, December 1974.

R. W. LYNCH, W. A. ROGERS, W. W. BRAYMEN, Aeroelastic tailoring of advanced composite structures of military aircraft, I. General study and II. Wing preliminary design, AFFDL-TR-76-100, U.S. Air Force Dynamics Lab, April 1977.

W. H. REED, J. T. FOUGHNER Jr., H. L. RUNYAN Jr., Decoupler pylon. A simple, effective wing/store flutter suppressor, J. Aircraft, 17, 3, 206-211, Match 1980.

R. N. DESMARAIS, W. H. REED, Wing/store flutter with nonlinear pylon stiffness, Proceedings AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS 21st Structures, Structural Dynamics and Materials Conference, Seattle, WA, 748-753, May 1980.

G. E. HODGES, Active flutter suppression - B-52 Controls configured vehicle, Paper No. 73-322, Proceedings, AIAA Dynamics Specialists Conf., Williamsburg, VA, March 1973.

K. L. ROGER, G. E. HODGES, L. FELT, Active-flutter suppression - a flight test demonstration, Paper No. 74-402, Proceedings, AIAA/ASME/SAE 15th Structures, Structural Dynamics and Materials Conf., Las Vegas, CA, April 1974. (See also papers in this same volume by REDD, GILMAN, COOLEY and SEVART; by SANDFORD, ABEL and GRAY; and by CWCH and STEARMAN).

E. N. MURROW, C. V. ECKSTROM, Drones for aerodynamic and structural testing (DAST) - a status report, J. Aircraft, 16, 8, 521-526, August 1979.

I. ABEL, J. R. NEWSOM, H. J. DUNN, Application of two synthesis methods Jor active flutter suppression on an aeroelastic wind tunnel model, AIAA Paper No. 79-1633, 1979.

A. CODIK, H. LIN, T. H. H. PIAN, Effect of structural flexibility on aircraft loading, Part 12 - The gust response of a sweptback tapered wing including bending flexibiity, A. F. Technical Report No. 6358, October 1953.

P. M. BURRIS, M. A. BENDER, Aircraft load alleviation and mode stabilization (LAMS), AFFDL­-TR-68-158, U.S. Air Force Flight Dynamics Lab, April 1969.

O. LILIENTHAL, Birdflight: the basis of aviation, Longmans, Green & Co., New York 1911.

J. L. G. F. PATRICK, Design and construction of a full scale ornithopter, Report of Staten Island Community College, 1960.

G. S. VASILEV, Principles of flight of models with flapping wings, B. B. Mikirtumov. Ed., pub­lished by G.I.O.D., Moscow 1953 (translation by Air Technical Intelligence Center, OH; available from Defense Documentation Center as AD-167 173).

J. WOLF, The technological prospects for oscillation wing propulsion of ultralight gliders, Pro­ceedings, 2nd Intl. Symposium on the Technology and Science of Low-Speed and Motorless Flight, Cambridge, MA, September 1974.

J. L. G. F. PATRICK, Natural flight and related aeronautics, 1969 Report on Beating Wings and Fins, The College of Staten Island, NY, 1969.

J. L. G. F. PATRICK, U.S. Patent No. 2,783,955, March 5, 1975.

J. L. G. F. PATRICK, Natural flight and related aeronautics, Paper No. FF-7, Inst. of Aeronau­tical Sciences, NY, 1952.

M. J. LIGHTHILL, Mathematical biofluiddynamics, Soc. Industrial and Applied Mathematics Philadelphia 1975.

Many autors, Swimming and flying in nature, 1, and 2, Plenum Press, NY, 1975.

I. E. GARRICK, Propulsion of a flapping and oscillating airfoil, NACA Report 557, 1936.

R. C. OBYE, Experimental measurement of lift and throust on an airfoil undergoing large ampli­tude motion, M. S. Thesis, Dept. Of Aerophysics and Aerospace Engineering, Mississippi State University, State College, MS, December 1972.

T. Y.-T. WU, Swimming of a waving plate, J. Fluid Mech., 10, Part 3, 321-344, 1961.

T. Y.-T. WU, Hydrodynamics of swimming propulsion: Parts 1, 2 and 3, J. Fluid Mech., 46, 337-355 Part 1, 1971; Part 3, 521-544, 1971, Part 3, 544-568, 1971.

T. Y.-T. WU, Extraction of flow energy by a wing oscillating in waves, J. Ship Research, 14, 1, 66-78, 1072.

M. G. CHOPRA, Large-amplitude lunate-tail of fish locomotion, J. Fluid Mech., 74, Part 1, 161-182, 1976.

M. G. CHOPRA, Hydromechanics of lunate-tail swimming propulsion, J. Fluid Mech., 54, Part 2, 357-391, 1974.

E. O. TUCK, The effect of spanwise variations in amplitude on the thrust-generating performance of a flapping thin wing, Swim.ming and Flying in Nature, 2, Plenum Press, NY, 953-973, 1975.

R. T. JONES, Wing flapping with minimum energy, NASA TM 81174, January 1980.

J. K. NATHMAN, Unsteady aerodynamic propulsion, Ph. D. Dissertation, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, 1981.

M. A. OSTGAARD, F. R. EWORTZEL, CCV's-Active control technology creating new military aircraft design potential, Astronautics and Aeronautics, 15, 2, 42-51, February 1977.